Confusion with the world 歌

Sometimes i happen to find on some texts the world 唄 instead of 歌, but when i search it on the vucabolary i find the second one. Something similar also happened for the kanji 川 and 河, which both means river. Are those just synonymes or are the the same kanji with two different ways of being written?

5 comments
  1. Those are just synonyms lol. Just looked it up myself bc I never knew about this. Kanji have similar meanings, so people apparently use them to write the same words sometimes

  2. There are a few kanji like that, they mean a similar enough thing for them to effectively be considered the same word, and they pretty much are interchangeable. Usually there is a more generic and common form – in this case I’d say 歌 is – and slightly more specific forms, such as 唄 (in this case having a maybe more emotional or atmospheric tone), or 詩 for a poetic tone. There are a few other related like 謳, 詠, 謡 which have more specific uses, you won’t see these as often. You should pick up the nuance by seeing what contexts they appear in/what other words they are part of, and a few dictionaries describe the differences.

    Some examples off the top of my head.
    いい・よい:良い、善い、好い、佳い
    わかる:分かる、判る、解る
    すでに:既に、已に

  3. Others can correct me if I’m wrong, but my understanding is that 唄 while a close synonym to 歌, implies an element of “Tradition” or “High Artistry” that 歌 alone does not imply. For example songs with a shamisen, or those sung in feudal Japanese courts, or sung/spoken poetry.

  4. Chinese brought with it a lot of kanji with similar or identical meanings, Japanese had to choose which ones to use. They eventually settled on things like 歌 and 川, but it wasn’t a direct process. If you look at old texts you will find plenty of cases using the “alternative” ones before they made up their minds.

Leave a Reply
You May Also Like